Why I Won’t Be Using Simplicity PrintSew Patterns Again

by Erin on January 13, 2012

So I was faffing about on Pinterest, and there was this great link from SewWeekly's Make This Look (isn't this dress lovely?): 

Makethislook_2180

I went to go check out the pattern (which is Simplicity 2180, not Butterick 2180, as it has in the image) and saw that Simplicity was now offering print-on-demand patterns. "Cool," I thought. (Insert ominous music here.)

I blithely entered my Paypal information and got a confirmation link to download my pattern. I should have read the FAQ first. 

So here are some of the ways the PrintSew process is borked:

– you can't download the pattern, and you can only print the pattern three times. This is stupid DRM-thinking: "Let's make it difficult to use the product we sold you, and that will stop piracy!" In three minutes I can figure out five ways to subvert this. (Hint: Photo. Copier.) All it really does is make it difficult for people who have bought the pattern to use it again. (And it seems as if their DRM doesn't even work — Firefox on the Mac downloaded the file without blinking, and Adobe Acrobat opened it right up again.)

– but before you can even print the pattern, you have to add an Adobe "FileOpen" plug-in. Oh, and did I mention you can't use the Chrome browser? And that the installation process is borked? If the installation fails with no error message (as mine did), here's what the ReadMe file says to do:

You can also place the plug-in manually into the Acrobat/Reader application. To do so, you must first find the appropriate plug-ins folder. You can find the Acrobat plug-ins folder in one of several ways:

  • Locate your copy of Acrobat or Adobe Reader and then find the Plug-ins folder. Typically this will be in locations like the following:

    /Applications/Adobe Reader 8/Adobe Reader.app
     ….

  • Acrobat/Reader 6 and later are packaged applications, so the Plug-Ins folder must be found by control-clicking the application icon and selecting Show Package Contents, then opening the folder Contents and within it the folder Plug-Ins. Paste the plug-in into this location. Note that the plug-in must not be placed in a sub-folder within Plug-Ins.
  • Search for another Acrobat plug-in, e.g. Acrofill or WebLink, and place the FileOpen plug-in into the same location. Note, however, that some Adobe plug-ins are installed into folders within the Plug-Ins folder; the FileOpen plug-in must not be placed into a sub-folder, it must be located in the root of the Plug-Ins folder.

How many people would even read the ReadMe? (I did because I compulsively read the ReadMes.) Oh, and it requires that Acrobat be your default PDF reader, too. This is flat-out dumb. It's ironic that Simplicity's tagline is "Creativity Made Simple!" because there is nothing simple about this. 

The PrintSew site does not inspire confidence, with icons out of the early 90s and messages like this:

Screen shot 2011-12-29 at 11.05.48 AM

Contrast this with BurdaStyle, which just lets you download a plain-vanilla PDF. That's how it should work. I recommend BurdaStyle downloads all the time, because they're great for people who are nervous or hesitant about working with tissue patterns. Screw it up? Print it out again! Heck, BurdaStyle should charge me a premium for their patterns, but they're some of the least-expensive ones out there (shh, don't tell them that). (And they also don't do the "list price is $20.99, but we'll do a 75% off sale every other week, okay?" rigamarole.)

Simplicity (and the other big pattern companies) need to figure this out pronto. I hardly ever go to their websites, and I hardly hardly ever go look at the books in the fabric store, either. If I'm looking for a new modern pattern to make I am much more likely to start with BurdaStyle or one of the other downloadable pattern sellers, because of the instant gratification factor. 

What do you think? Have you converted to printable patterns for your non-vintage sewing? Where do you find good downloadable printable patterns aside from BurdaStyle? Or do you prefer traditional tissue paper? (I also know lots of you draft your own patterns: I bow humbly in your direction.)

{ 54 comments… read them below or add one }

Netter January 13, 2012 at 5:46 am

How ironic that Simplicity is now selling print BurdaStyle patterns on their website! Thanks for the heads up. The only downloadable sewing patterns I’ve used are Hot Patterns offered free on fabric.com.

Reply

paige @ luxperdiem January 13, 2012 at 5:51 am

I hate having to tape everything together so I normally, on the rare occasion I do print at home versions of patterns, take the file to kinkos for the print at the copy shop option.
I also refuse to pay non indie pattern companies more than the 1.99 sale price. I think it’s pretty funny that the print at home version is the same cost for simplicity as the paper version. How does that make any sense?

Reply

Claire (aka Seemane) January 13, 2012 at 5:55 am

I’ve used PrintSew – this is what I do.
I installed the free PDF printer ‘PrimoPDF’ onto my laptop – basically your PC thinks that PrimoPDF (http://www.primopdf.com/) is a real live printer-machine, but instead of churning out paper, it creates a PDF file for you (I tell it to send the files to the Desktop, where I can find them easily + move them to wherever I want).

Then when I get prompted to ‘print to paper’ I actually print it to PDF – that way i get to keep the file at home easily to use whenever I want :)

Reply

Melissa March 7, 2013 at 11:21 am

The PrimoPDF way doesn’t seem to be working for me…unless I’m setting it up wrong. They must’ve changed the security on the files.

Reply

Laura September 30, 2013 at 10:57 pm

Claire- I thought what a great idea, and downloaded primopdf. But all I get is “Invalid printer selected. Printing to this device is not allowed.” I had no idea I get to use it only 3 times. I have already “used it twice” just from experimental downloading and not printing. I had wanted to make a jacket for me and another for my aunt. I also expected the software would give me some other options, like making the pattern a bit shorter, So I don’t have to cut and measure and tack the paper pieces.

At first I thought it was a great idea. I don’t think I would be using it again! :(

The price is definantely not the value of getting to print 3 times!!!

Reply

Kristie January 30, 2014 at 3:21 pm

Another great PDF printer is pdf995.
There’s a pop-up every time you use it, asking you to pay, kinda like winrar, just say you’re still happy with the trial! ;)

Reply

Lynn January 13, 2012 at 5:57 am

I haven’t tried printable patterns and I can’t imagine liking them, for the reason Paige said – having to tape everything together. I do like tissue paper patterns but I also like Kwik Sew, which are printed on thicker paper.

Reply

Laura Miller January 13, 2012 at 6:07 am

After using pattern software for a time, I began to HATE the tape process of putting the patterns together; so I do not download patterns. When I can pick them up for 99 cents, the price offsets my time, my paper, my ink, my headache. So I put off that instant gratification of a pattern until it is on sale, I might even buy 2 of the same pattern cause I will cut it for 99 cents. I have gotten to the point I like to sew, I don’t want to print patterns, I don’t want to trace … on the other side I agree that Simplicity needs to make it simple & generic to the software used for the processes. I use Chrome for my browser, FoxIt for my PDF files, so I would be more the peeved at them. All MHO …

Reply

AnaJan January 13, 2012 at 6:22 am

Last year I wrote a post about all the websites I knew that offered patterns for download. Some of them are free of charge, while the others are pay for. Here’s the list. I try to update it whenever I find new links.

Reply

AnaJan January 13, 2012 at 6:23 am

P.S. the hypertext didn’t work in the previous comment, so I’ll just copy the link:

http://stepalica.blogspot.com/2011/06/pitanja-i-odgovori-deo-ii-q-part-2.html

Reply

Nathalie January 13, 2012 at 6:23 am

I can’t be doing with the faffing involved in downloading patterns. Then printing. Then taping. Then cutting the pattern pieces. And if you want to store the pieces on tissue paper rather than printing paper (which takes up 4x the storage space), you then have the extra stage of transferring them over and cutting some more… You may get instant gratification of purchase but there’s nothing instant thereafter.

One of the many reasons I like vintage patterns is that they mostly arrive cut already or non printed, with pieces that require nothing other than tracing away onto the fabric (or muslin, if I’m really pulling out the stops).

I don’t think I’ll ever use BurdaStyle for that very reason.

Reply

Katherine @ WeSewRetro January 13, 2012 at 7:14 am

I lost interest in Simplicity’s downloadable patterns when I saw they charge an additional 20% for people outside the US.

This is the internet, Simplicity. It does not cost you more to send a digital product to another continent.

Reply

laura January 13, 2012 at 7:27 am

This is the worst possible implementation of something you can buy online I’ve seen in a while. The big pattern companies are lucky sewing isn’t mainstream – with this sort of implementation, they would be riddled with piracy if it were, just like movie companies.

It’s just another case of companies being late to the game and not understanding that people will buy their stuff if you make it easy for them to do so. Cheap and DRM-free will sell way more than expensive and DRMed. Gah. So annoying, I just don’t understand how they have sales people missing the basic point of INTERNET sales.

Reply

Lauren January 13, 2012 at 8:33 am

I’ve done a few downloadable patterns and it’s just not my thing. I hate fiddling with the paper and tape. Cutting is my least favorite part of sewing, so I’d rather have it already all laid out for me on a big sheet.

Reply

Carolyne January 13, 2012 at 8:37 am

Downloading seems such a drudge in the first place!
*Vintage* are cost effective, with infinite creative possibilities. Why use someone else’s idea of modernizing the vintage when your own scissors can create a beauty for your closet?

Reply

kbeer January 13, 2012 at 9:22 am

I *love* this rant (completely justified!) against all the obstacles put in the customer’s way. (And the above comment–that international customers pay a 20% surcharge?! for a web download?!?–I am floored!)

More than that, I’m grateful to you for the heads up–I will not be bothering with Simplicity’s “downloadable” patterns.

Reply

LinB January 13, 2012 at 9:29 am

Tissue paper patterns are relatively cheap, especially when you get them on sale. Print-them-myself patterns cost me paper, tape, printer ink, aggravation and paper cuts. I have to REALLY want a downloadable pattern, and it has to be COMPLETELY unavailable in a similar style at the fabric store. Oh, and tissue patterns usually come with suggestions for fabric layout and instructions for construction that have been proofread, and that I don’t have to also print out myself. So, tissue for me, please.

Reply

Colleen January 13, 2012 at 10:00 am

Another thing to be said about buying the big name tissue patterns on-line:

I ordered a few from the McCall’s line–two on clearance, one regular price (club member’s price) late Sunday night. I realized just after placing the order that I had ordered the full-price one in the wrong size. Customer service was not open until the next morning.

I called first thing in the morning my time (two hour difference) and inquired. They insisted the order was already processed and could not be changed, but once I received the pattern I could send it back with a money order for $4 shipping and have it exchanged for the correct size.

I then totalled it up–$6 for the money order from Canada Post, $4 shipping, and about $2.50 to ship it back. I might as well just buy the pattern again in the correct size–it would cost me the same.

Up until then, I’m not too bugged about it. I should have checked before finalizing the order.

What DOES burn me is receiving the e-mail THURSDAY MORNING that my order has been shipped. The order that on MONDAY MORNING they couldn’t possibly change because it was already being processed.

I’ll still deal with them, but I would warn everyone to be very careful when ordering.

Reply

Kate in England January 13, 2012 at 10:04 am

I ordered a downloadable Simplicity pattern (I’m in the UK) and it took them A WEEK just to send me the Printsew link. Paper patterns I’d ordered from Vogue/Butterick/McCalls at the same time arrived faster. I was NOT impressed. I haven’t even tried to print it, and, generally speaking, with the cost of printer ink I don’t think I will bother with printable patterns much in the future.

I must say, I have been really pleasantly surprised by the the B/M/Vogue website – wait for the sales and the patterns are massively cheaper than they are here in the UK (where we don’t have JoAnns or anywhere that sells patterns at a discount), and they ship really quickly.

Reply

MB@YarnUiPhoneAppv2.1 January 13, 2012 at 10:16 am

I may be the odd gal out..but I love the Simplicity patterns…the ones you find at Hancock or Jo-Ann Fabrics. They seem to fit me (especially at the shoulders) with few mods.

Reply

Cyberdaze.wordpress.com January 13, 2012 at 10:25 am

I like the idea of downloadable patterns but I confess I still use tissue. I don’t have a printer at home and so I’d have to take downloadables to the copy shop. Perhaps if I didn’t have a Burda subscription already I might do it. I completely agree with you about the DRM. It’s no protection for Simplicity and a real pain in the neck for the consumer.

Reply

sarah January 13, 2012 at 10:25 am

I won’t use a pattern that requires me to print it, tape it, cut it, etc. No thanks. I make a list of stuff I want from their website, and when I’m in the mood I stalk sales and shop away when they are 1.99 or .99. I barely even use 1/4 of the patterns I buy anyway (eyes way bigger than time in this case).

Reply

Steph A January 13, 2012 at 10:27 am

I just read the announcement about Simplicity selling BurdaStyle patterns too, and I just hope it’s not as kaffufly as the process for their own stuff. What a headache!

I agree with Claire (aka Seemane), 3rd comment, about using PrimoPDF. I’ve been using that on my laptop for over a year and love it. It’s so easy to use.

Reply

Thread Ov Metal January 13, 2012 at 10:37 am

Yikes! DRM-ugh!

Thanks for the detailed info!

Reply

bb January 13, 2012 at 12:14 pm

I’m not sure if this applies, but on a Mac you can save a PDF from any Print dialog box. When it pops up to select printer, etc. just look over in the lower left hand corner.

Reply

Heather January 13, 2012 at 1:00 pm

I love the tissue paper patterns. I think I’m just nostalgic. I like the sound the tissue makes and the feel. It makes me think of my mother sewing when I was a little girl. Since patterns are sold in multi-sizes, I still trace them off on pattern fabric. It isn’t much more work than printing and cutting and taping would be. So, chalk my love of tissue up to good ol’ nostalgia.

Reply

velosewer January 13, 2012 at 1:06 pm

What a crock. Why bother then. There’s way too much competition now. Thank you for this post.

Reply

NessyS January 13, 2012 at 4:17 pm

Yes indeedy-do. I’ve bitched (sorry but this gets me really mad) about these very points on BurdaStyle forums before. I really do hate PrintSew for the reasons you’ve listed and more. One main beef I have with them is that if you want to save your “expensive” home printer ink and say, print the pdf file more cheaply at a print store or the public library you can’t because these places won’t let you download the program required to print these documents (it is against their policy because of fear of viruses – and fair enough too) so you can’t. Also – the pattern layout is very poor – it is almost if they have designed it to use as much paper and ink as possible. For example – say you want a size 12 – it will give the other sizes printed as separate pieces on separate pages so you print off a lot more than you really need – and considering some of the patterns go up to a size 22 that is a lot of waste (and it is really tricky to identify the pages you actually do need to avoid printing ones you don’t). The whole thing is a crock and I refuse to use them!!!! Go team BurdaStyle – they are a model for how things should be done!

Reply

Emily @ Make It Happen Mama January 13, 2012 at 7:17 pm

Ugh, how irritating! I’ve never even been on the Simplicity web site, but I LOOOOVE browsing BurdaStyle. They have so many cute patterns, and even a ton of free ones that I love to download and experiment with. Thanks for the honest review – it’s good to know that Simplicity online isn’t worth messing with!

Reply

sam January 14, 2012 at 4:11 am

I love Burdastyle and being able to download patterns! I’ve only just started sewing, and I absolutely love that if there’s a pattern I maybe like the look of, I can click on “finished projects” and see aaalll the variations made by other people, with different fabrics, for different body shapes, different necklines, hems, etc. VERY handy for a newbie to see how things 1) can be tweaked, and, 2) look on a real human, as opposed to the gorgeous, but totally unrealistic pattern sketches.

The sticky-taping up of the print out *is* extremely tiresome, but I do like the sturdiness of paper as opposed to tissue. And I’m currently too slack to trace the pattern onto something (I just cut immediately), so I love being able to re-print whenever I like, eg, to make again for a smaller friend.

And as a possibly strange bonus, I travel a lot for work, so as with digital music and books, I like having digital patterns on my laptop, so when I’m stuck in strange cities/towns/mine sites, I can still pore over my pattern collection, dreaming and scheming what to make next when I’m home again:) (what I call “my precious-ing”)

Reply

Susan January 14, 2012 at 8:04 am

Thanks for this post, Erin! Everything about the post and the comments has been interesting and helpful to me. I haven’t tried downloadable patterns (except for a few craft freebies) and I found the remarks from other sewers very interesting. Also, I hadn’t known about Sew Weekly, much less the Make This Look feature–so now I have a new site to bookmark, as well as useful information and lively, helpful discussion. This blog and its readers are the best! Thanks again!!

Reply

Missmerryheart January 15, 2012 at 7:55 pm

I’m sorry your experience was so unpleasant (I’m not a fan of clothing pattern downloads myself, even from Burda– too much work involved, what with all that taping) but at least your post brought a delightful dress pattern to my attention. :-) Hancock had Simplicity on sale for $1 so I ran out yesterday and got one in my size. I’ve already pulled out fabric from my stash and can’t wait to get started!

Reply

Joni January 16, 2012 at 5:34 am

I can’t imagine downloading a person-sized sewing pattern and printing and assembling it myself. I loathe the way computer paper wrinkles when you pin it, and it’s near impossible to fold it up neatly once it’s been taped. I just wait for the 99 cent sales or, more likely, buy vintage.

Ironically, I use almost nothing but PDF patterns for my doll sewing biz – but that’s because doll clothes pattern pieces are so small, there is little or no taping (and it’s such a niche market online is the only way to go). Even then, I will trace them onto interfacing or something because I hate pinning computer paper.

Reply

YYZ January 16, 2012 at 6:23 pm

Have never tried the downloadable pattern thing, but have long believed “Simplicity” to be the most mis-named pattern company out there…

Reply

Roslyn January 19, 2012 at 3:12 pm

I could not agree with you more on Printsew! I live in Barbados so was hoping that this would have been easier than waiting for patterns to be delivered. Using PrimoPDF didn’t work for me either, so I’m not bothering again. Its not worth it.

Reply

Mona January 20, 2012 at 12:37 pm

Thank you for your helpful post. I found it after googling an issue I had with setting up the PrintSew FileOpen plugin. The PrintSew setup is really from the dark ages of the internet. I finally figured out that I had to select size and paper format before the request to install the plugin was no longer displayed and the pattern opened. On the other hand the PrintSew customer support was very friendly (they answered my help ticket within minutes and simply supplied me with a working link). Another thing to consider: They link your account to a specific computer, which is very annoying if you need to print it from another one, e.g. at a friend’s place workplace if you do not own a printer. If you want another computer authorized you need to contact customer service.

Reply

Kalinchen.wordpress.com January 23, 2012 at 10:59 am

I always buy the Burda magazines, then the patterns are even cheaper :) But occasionally I also use their download and as you say, it’s so easy and works perfectly – go Burda!

Reply

EdieG1 February 8, 2012 at 1:59 pm

That’s shocking bad customer service. No need for that rigmarole. I use burdastyle and, yea, it’s fiddly but here, in Ireland you are paying the equivalent of $15 for a basic paper pattern and they are NEVER on sale of available in charity shops so I can get about 4-5 burda patterns for the price of 1 shop bought pattern.

Reply

Fraise.wordpress.com February 11, 2012 at 10:01 am

Here in France I can buy the Burda magazine, and since it’s only 6 euros (with the paper patterns, heavier than tissue), I go that route when an issue has patterns I like. But. I’ve found their skirts to be seriously wonky, to the point where I won’t make them any more.

I visit the big-name patternmaker websites all the time for inspiration after seeing looks I like in stores. I only buy from them on sale, though, and like you say they do it pretty often. I finally got a couple designer patterns recently (on sale too! $30 at regular price, yeesh), and have to say they are really nice. Their directions give accurate couture techniques, which impressed me. Long story short, their tissue patterns have always been worth it – I’ve never had problems with them like I have with Burda ones. Just today I took apart the last wonky Burda skirt I’ll ever make, and re-cut it to a McCall’s pattern that turned out beautifully. I do wish they’d use more normally-sized women as models, but on Facebook they’re pretty awesome about sharing people’s projects in all sizes. Worlds better than Burda, who always seem to showcase tiny women.

Burda dresses and trousers can really be great though! Still wearing some Burda capris I made years ago.

Reply

Alyssia February 14, 2012 at 12:40 pm

I have bought about12 patterns through print sew. I wasn’t aware of the limits on printing but suspected there might be. I do get tired of the printing and taping, and then add to taht I copy the size pattern I want onto tracing vellum So I am not cutting up my original. Talk about alot of work. I an’t stand using my printer paper for cutting from. it just doesn’t sit right on teh fabric for a nice cut. Thanks for your info though. First I have stumbled across.

Reply

angie.a February 19, 2012 at 7:41 am

I’ve done a couple of print at home patterns (actually sewed them up, I mean), and have some BurdaStyle downloaded and ready but haven’t printed them yet. I really hate the taping together part. I dislike heavy paper for patterns too (I know I’m in the minority) and prefer the feel of tissue. I mostly sew with vintage patterns these days or if I’m going modern, with Burda’s magazine patterns.

Reply

Tina March 5, 2012 at 1:55 pm

Thanks for the post! I wish I read this before I purchased the patterns from simplicity.com. They really make it impossible to print out the stuff I paid for. I don’t have a printer at home. The public computer at Staples doesn’t allow me to download anything plugins for security reasons. And I still have no clue how I can print this out … I know one thing for sure, I will not buy any printables from simplicity until they change their printsew site.

Reply

Barbara March 6, 2012 at 4:26 pm

OK here’s what the pattern companies need to do! . . . (Think the Wal-Mart or CostCo service where you upload your photos and then go pick up the pictures from the local store.)
First upload your measurements, then pick your pattern, “Smart Pattern Co.” sends electronic file of pattern adjusted to your perfect measurements to your local Kinko’s and you run over and pick it up, or receive it in the mail next day. There was a company doing this for a while, but i guess demand was low and they went out of business, plus they were doing the print & tape and trace thing. Even better if Kinko’s could print on tissue but that may be hoping for too much. Since the measurements are so specific, there would be less reason for piracy.
Now that is a service I would pay for. (First one is free to check fit!!)
I would be a customer for life.
Now that we have Blurb . . . and computers are everywhere and 4th graders can program in C++ I am expecting to see this soon! (Burda are you listening??)

Reply

Margarita March 20, 2012 at 12:57 pm

Hello! I have just today bought a pattern from simplicity.com and it don´t work, I have installed the plu-in and adove reader as standardized program for pdf format to reader but it dont work, I don´t recommend this website to anyone.

Reply

Kaven March 30, 2012 at 3:36 am

I have no choice but to use it as I am from Malaysia and is too expensive to ship over. :(

Reply

irene December 25, 2012 at 3:00 pm

This happened to me too!!! So awful and so frustrated! But now I guess I’ll try the burda website!

Reply

irene December 25, 2012 at 3:09 pm

Also don’t use butterick either! They both don’t work at all

Reply

Amanda April 20, 2013 at 11:29 pm

I wish I had read this before buying patterns at print sew. I can’t even figure out what the error message means when I try to download the plugin, and I have a feeling they’re flat out going to steal my money. And yes, Burda is the greatest.

Reply

Laura September 30, 2013 at 11:17 pm

I tried Primopdf, go message “Invalid printer selected – printing to this device is not allowed.”

Especially disappointing when I have already used up 2 of my 3 print allowances just messing around trying to find out how it works.

I also had some idea the software would allow me to make alterations before printing.

Will not be purchasing this again!

Reply

sharon October 1, 2013 at 4:43 am

I just bought a pattern as well, the rigmarole you have to go to just to download the pattern, compared to other sites, its just not worth it. Then when I did print it out, the writing is so small I cant even read it. It doesn’t tell you how much material you need. it just shows the photo of the bag. I think I might try and get a refund.

Reply

sharon October 2, 2013 at 3:17 am

The new kwik sew patters are now on tissue paper (2013)
I wish I had read all the posts before purchasing and agonising over the simple idea of printing a pattern.

Reply

Laura October 2, 2013 at 10:52 am

I tried primopdf at your recommendation. Perhaps it work in January 2012. They must have plugged the “bug”. :P

I am going to call them and try to get my $ back.

It doesn’t work for me.

Reply

Michelle December 14, 2013 at 5:58 pm

I will not use PrintSew, they bilked me for a pattern that was downloadable for any reason. I did load two others, but one would not. I sent more than one request for assistance, never heard from them.
No second chances from me.

Reply

Amber March 21, 2014 at 4:19 am

Wow, two years after you wrote this post and nothing has changed! I just downloaded one and first, it took forever to get emailed and now I’ve wasted 45 minutes trying to figure out how to down load it. What a waste of precious sewing time! I’m spoiled with indie designers I guess. NEVER again.

Reply

Leave a Comment

Previous post:

Next post: